The Federal High Court in Abuja has explained why it nullified the emergence of Senator David Mark and other leaders of the African Democratic Congress (ADC).
Justice Peter Lifu gave the judgment on November 5, 2026, following a leadership dispute involving Nafiu Bala Gombe and the Mark-led faction of the party.
The judge said the decision was based on three major issues: a disputed resignation letter, the limits of the party’s National Executive Committee (NEC) powers and the failure to prove that the new leaders were elected democratically.
Disputed resignation letter
The Mark-led faction argued that Nafiu Bala Gombe had resigned as ADC Deputy National Chairman on May 17, 2025, before the party appointed its new leaders.
However, Justice Lifu rejected the resignation letter after comparing its signature with Gombe’s signatures on other official documents.
The judge said there were clear differences between the signatures and concluded that they did not appear to belong to the same person.
He described the letter as possibly fabricated and said it could not be accepted as reliable evidence that Gombe had resigned.
The judge clarified that this was a finding in a civil case and not a criminal conviction for forgery.
NEC cannot ignore the lawThe court also ruled that the ADC’s National Executive Committee could not use its powers to remove existing party leaders and appoint new ones without following the law.
The judge explained that although political parties have the freedom to manage their internal affairs, they must follow the Nigerian Constitution and electoral laws.
He relied on the 1999 Constitution and the Electoral Act 2022, which require political parties to conduct democratic elections for their principal officers and executive committees.
He said the NEC’s administrative powers did not give it the right to replace elected leaders without following the required democratic process.
No evidence of a democratic electionAnother major reason for the judgment was the failure of the Mark-led faction to provide sufficient evidence that its members were elected through a democratic process.
The faction argued that it had informed the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) about the NEC meeting and that the commission monitored the meeting.
However, Justice Lifu said informing INEC and allowing it to monitor a meeting did not prove that a proper election took place.
He explained that there was no sufficient evidence that party members or elected delegates were allowed to participate and vote for their preferred candidates.
Court rejects internal affairs argument
The defendants also argued that the disagreement was an internal party matter that should not be decided by the court.
But Justice Lifu rejected the argument, saying courts could intervene when a political party’s actions appeared to violate the Constitution or electoral laws.
He also ruled that Gombe was not required to exhaust the party’s internal dispute resolution process before approaching the court in the circumstances of the case.
What the court ordered
Following its findings, the court:
- Nullified the emergence of David Mark and other disputed ADC executives.
- Cancelled the decisions taken at the party’s 99th NEC meeting held on July 29, 2025.
- Stopped the affected executives from presenting themselves as legitimate party leaders.
- Declared Nafiu Bala Gombe the only elected member of the National Working Committee (NWC) whose four-year tenure was still valid.
- Recognised Gombe’s right to supervise the affairs of the party
- However, the judge clarified that the ruling did not automatically make Gombe the National Chairman of the ADC.
- The court’s decision was based on its findings that Gombe’s resignation had not been established, the NEC could not ignore constitutional requirements and the Mark-led faction had failed to prove that its emergence followed a proper democratic election.
- The judge stressed that political parties must obey the Nigerian Constitution and electoral laws when choosing their leaders.